Bringing the Employer into Disrepute
Employees can at times be charged with being a representative of their employer even when they are not at work.
Employers are mostly concerned with what their employees do while they are at work but occasionally the employee’s behaviour on their own time can have a detrimental effect on the employer. It’s important for employers to take action in this situation – as ex England Manager, Sam Allardyce, discovered in 2016.
Bringing the employer into disrepute
When employees behave in a particular way in their private lives, those activities may be considered inappropriate because of the nature of their employment. It may be the case that the actions could become associated with the employer and have a negative impact on the business; undermine the public values of the employer or cause embarrassment to the employer: in other words, bring the employer into disrepute.
Examples of behaviour
The type of behaviour which can bring an employer into disrepute is wide and varied and can often depend on the particular industry of the employer, but here are some examples:
- England’s Football Manager explaining how to circumvent practices that are banned by the Football Association, and appearing to accept an offer of money to advise on them;
- A primary school teacher who posed for photos used in a glamour model website;
- A delivery driver who made what was labelled a ‘bomb threat’ to security personnel in Canary Wharf when he was unhappy at the time taken to undertake a security check on his van.
What can an employer do about it?
Employees can be disciplined and dismissed for bringing their employer into disrepute. Ideally, in the employee’s contractual documentation there will be a clause reserving the right for the employer to take action in relation to behaviour undertaken outside of work. However, even where this isn’t the case, employers may be able to rely on a breach of mutual trust and confidence to initiate disciplinary proceedings. A written contract does not need to contain a reference to this because it is an implied term in the employer/employee relationship.
How should a procedure be approached?
Regardless of how damaging the behaviour may appear at first instance, employers should consider the following:
- Undertake a full investigation of the situation. Unfair dismissal cases often fall down because the employer has jumped the gun and not ascertained the facts.
- If the alleged action could amount to gross misconduct if substantiated, consider a suspension whilst the investigation is done.
- Establish whether or not the alleged behaviour directly affects your reputation as an organisation.
- Determine if the behaviour caused complaints from customers/clients.
- Don’t use your own standards as a barometer for taking action. Just because you personally do not approve does not mean that the employee’s behaviour has the effect of bringing the organisation into disrepute.
Not just senior employees
It isn’t just the Sam Allardyces of the world who are liable to allegations of bringing the employer into disrepute. It can apply to all levels of employee and sanctions applied should be determined on the severity of the allegation itself.
Are You A Business Owner?
Business Owners and Company Directors can get definitive answers to all your HR, Employment Law and Health & Safety questions from our experts.
Free Access To ‘HR24 Answers’ Expert Advice
Free Access To HR Template Documents
Free Access To H&S Template Documents
Free Access To Local Training Masterclasses
Click on the green button below to find out more about free HR24 membership for business owners and company directors.